The Steel City boasts one of the oldest and proudest franchises in the NFL. The Pittsburgh Steelers boast a history littered with legendary players, rabid fans, and iconic moments. But now with the 2025 season beginning, one prevailing question weighs over Pittsburgh like the autumn fog that wraps Heinz Field this time of year, who will be the starting quarterback?

No position in American football carries as much weight as the quarterback, and the QB battle in Pittsburgh has become the centrepiece of the Steelers 2025 season and the season for the rest of the league. The franchise has talented candidates on the roster, but who will separate themselves and rise to the occasion to answer the call to lead under centre?

This article will give a extensive overview of the Pittsburgh Steelers QB battle going on, laying out the main contenders, their strengths and weaknesses, past performances, any updates from pre-season games, and what it means for the Steelers season ahead.

Why The QB Battle Matters For The Steelers

The Steelers are not any NFL franchise – they symbolize an identity of toughness, resiliency and success. Since the retirement of Ben Roethlisberger, they have been searching for stability at the most important position in football. 

Their offence has been consistently inconsistent. 

They have one of the best defenses in football; however, without a competent quarterback, it’s tough to achieve playoff success. 

Fans want to clearly see what direction and identity the franchise is going to take. 

With a settled quarterback, they could be the difference between just clinching a playoff spot versus legitimately competing for another Super Bowl.

The Main Contenders For The Steelers QB Role In 2025

Let's explore the top contenders for the starting role: 

Kenny Pickett - The young prospect drafted to be the future. 
Russell Wilson - The veteran with championship experience. 
Justin Fields - The dual-threat quarterback with upside. 
Wildcard Options - Depth players or possibly moves midseason.

Player Profiles And Analysis

Kenny Pickett - The Homegrown Hope

Kenny Pickett, a first-round draft pick in the 2022 NFL Draft, emerged as an obvious heir to Big Ben. He is from Pittsburgh and that resonated with the fans. 
Strengths:
 Comfortable in the pocket
 Leadership
 Accuracy on short-intermediate throws 
Weaknesses:
 Deep throws are a weakness
 Inconsistency with pressure
Limited mobility compared to modern QBs
Pickett has shown some flashes but some analysts have argued that he has not developed as quickly as they would have liked.

Russell Wilson – The Veteran Leader

Russell Wilson joined the Steelers late in his career in hopes of revitalizing his game, after a very successful career with Super Bowl winning days with the Seattle Seahawks. Wilson is a proven winner and will add veteran leadership and big game experience.

Strengths:

Proven winner and playoff experience.

Strong arm, deep-ball accuracy.

Ability to shine in clutch moments.

Weaknesses:

Age and decline of physical ability.

Inconsistent performances in recent years.

Almost certainly won't fit perfectly into the Steelers’ scheme of offense.

Wilson could be a bridge to a younger quarterback while mentoring.

Justin Fields – The Dual-Threat Option

Brought in to inject life into the offence, Fields brings a different skill set to the table. His running ability and arm strength can turn games on a dime. 

Strengths:

Elite agility and athleticism.

Very strong arm and ability to extend plays.

Excellent in red-zone situations.

Weaknesses:

Still developing as a passer.

Can struggle with decision making.

Needs a system that plays to his strengths.

If the Steelers modify their playbook then Fields could be a long-term solution.

Wildcard Options

While the three main names dominate the headlines, the NFL is unpredictable. Injuries, trades, or even breakout performances from backups could shake up the QB room mid-season.

Statistical Comparison Table

Here’s a simplified comparison of the three key contenders based on recent seasons:

Coaching And System Fit

Head coach Mike Tomlin will be heavily involved in this battle. Tomlin is known for his defensive background and leadership practices, he's going to have to decide if he wants:

A veteran stability (Wilson),

A developmental plan (Pickett), or

A dynamic dual-threat (Fields).

The offensive coordinator's scheme will also play a role in determining who fits best.

Fan Expectations And Pressure

Steelers Nation is one of the most involved fanbases in the NFL. They expect results and aren’t settled for mediocrity. 

If Pickett starts, everyone will want to see growth. 

If Wilson starts, everyone will be expecting instant wins. 

If Fields starts, everyone will be expecting exciting, creative football. 

The QB that can handle the pressure will win!

"It was a critical play in the game. But that's the Sam we know and love."

In a big moment Sunday, Sam Darnold broke free from a would-be sack, and Seattle's offense broke out vs. Pittsburgh after its disappointing debut.https://t.co/pV70uwcUHA

— Brady Henderson (@BradyHenderson) September 15, 2025

Possible Scenarios For 2025

Pickett Breakout Year - He steps up and shows he can lead the team.

Wilson's Last Hoorah - Wilson has one more solid year of play before retiring.

Fields Era Begins - Steel City builds the future around Fields.

Mid-Season Shift - Struggles force a decision mid-season.

Long-Term Implications

This decision isn't just a 2025 decision. It's a decision that can shape the next decade for the Steelers. 

Choosing Pickett means investment and patience. 

Choosing Wilson means short-term priority. 

Choosing Fields means a gamble on upside.